The advantage and disadvantages of portfolios over standardized test for students

Additionally, no valid grading criteria as of yet have been established to evaluate quality of generated portfolios. Critical thinking skills, creative assessment, selectivity and reflective analysis are also enhanced.

David C. Alternative assessment includes long-form responses and essay questions. However, these machine grading methods require standardized prompts. For example, are the critical writing skills of our students on a par with those of students at comparable institutions and if below, what might be done to improve their performance?

advantages of portfolio assessment in early childhood education

To protect the anonymity of contributors, we've removed their names and personal information from the essays. In an article last year in Academe, Gerald Graff and Cathy Birkenstein pointed out that many faculty erroneously equate standardized exams with the highly questionable multiple-choice tests that characterize the implementation of the No Child Left Behind Act.

They wanted the focus of writing to be on revision, collaboration, and student growth, rather than scoring and ranking. Performance-based assessments have disadvantages for students who may not feel overly creative or willing to present their knowledge in front of a large group.

They these instructors would probably agree -- or should agree -- that college-educated students, regardless of their background or major, should be critical thinkers, meaning that, at a minimum, they should be able to read a college-level text, offer a pertinent summary of its central claim, and make a relevant response, whether by agreeing with it, complicating its claims, or offering a critique.

Pros and cons of student portfolios

Test makers can categorize questions to determine which areas students excel in and which they have difficulty with. For example, they might be used to provide information about the range of tasks and activities students engage in and their views about the importance of different aspects of their education and campus experiences. Most helpful essay resource ever! Until , these tests had to be graded by hand — then the first automatic test scanner was invented by IBM. They do not and cannot yield the trustworthy information that is needed for this purpose. They also lack chances to demonstrate their reasoning skills despite a lack of knowledge about a question's specific subject matter. Because of the inherent problems with portfolios, they do not and cannot provide trustworthy, unbiased, or cost effective information about student learning. Assessment is an essential part of education. Uncover new sources by reviewing other students' references and bibliographies Inspire new perspectives and arguments or counterarguments to address in your own essay Read our Academic Honor Code for more information on how to use and how not to use our library. McClelland's paper , provided the key to authenticity with standardization. Without standardization, faculty and administrators at individual campuses cannot answer the fundamental questions: Is the amount of student learning and level of achievement attained by the students at our campus good enough?

Alternative assessment allows educators to focus on critical reasoning skills, which students will be able to apply naturally to long-form test questions.

Rated 9/10 based on 6 review
The Disadvantages of Performance